Your Employees Are Already Using AI

Michael P. McCready, founder and Managing Partner of McCready Law, a Chicago-headquartered personal injury firm he launched in 1999 and has grown over 27 years into more than 20 attorneys and 13 offices across seven states, starts the AI governance conversation from an assumption most executives have not made yet: the tools are already in use inside your company, approved or not. Glenn Gow, The Scaling Executive Coach and host of The Scaling Executive Podcast, identifies that gap as the one leaving firms exposed while leadership debates whether to adopt anything. When employees are using AI on their own, the default data-sharing settings on consumer LLMs will expose client information unless a leader has written a policy, documented the processes, and required a named human to take responsibility for every output, which McCready treats as his job rather than his IT department’s.

This episode is for founders and managing partners of professional services firms who have not yet written an AI policy and assume that means their firm is not using AI.

Key Takeaways

  • The adoption question is already settled without you. Michael P. McCready’s position is that if you believe nobody in your business is using AI, you are mistaken, which makes a written policy a current requirement rather than a future one.
  • Privacy exposure comes from a default setting most staff have never seen. McCready points out that these systems share your data by default to improve the model, and that a partner may know to turn that off while a paralegal does not.
  • Accountability has to attach to a person. McCready requires a human to sign off on any AI output and take responsibility for having checked it, backed by an audit trail.
  • Mistakes are not the argument against AI that people think. McCready’s framing is that a corrected AI error will not recur, while telling a person what they did wrong guarantees nothing.
  • The billing model is the part at risk, not the profession. McCready says lawyers who use AI will replace lawyers who do not, and that clients will refuse to keep funding junior grunt work AI now handles.

Leaders Write AI Policy Because Their Teams Are Already Using the Tools

Michael P. McCready, founder and Managing Partner of McCready Law, dismisses the wait-and-see posture outright. He hears people say they do not trust AI yet because it makes mistakes, and he answers that the mistake argument cuts the other way: a corrected AI error will not be repeated, while correcting a person guarantees nothing about the next attempt.

That does not make the tool self-governing. “You cannot just let AI run rampant.”

His starting assumption is the part most leaders skip. “If you don’t think someone is not using AI, you’re sadly mistaken. Everyone is using AI, whether you know it or not.” A firm without a policy does not have zero AI use. It has unmonitored AI use.

The specific exposure he names is one most staff will never discover on their own. The default behavior of these systems is to share your data to improve the model, and switching that off requires knowing the setting exists. McCready’s point is about the distribution of that knowledge inside a firm: he knows, the host knows, and the secretary and the paralegal handling client information do not. That gap is a leadership failure rather than a user error, which is why he ties it to documented processes rather than a reminder email.

Governance elementWhat McCready requiresWhat it prevents
Written AI policyA stated firm position on what may be used and for whatUnmonitored tool use across a 170-person organization
Data sharing controlsExplicit instruction that default data sharing is turned offClient information entering a training corpus through a staff member who never saw the setting
Human sign-offA person signs off on every AI output and takes responsibility for checking itHallucinated content reaching a client or a court unverified
Audit trailDocumented processes showing accountability for each useNo way to trace an error back to a decision or a person

Leaders Address the Job Question Directly Before the Team Fills the Silence

Michael P. McCready, founder and Managing Partner of McCready Law, treats the fear as reasonable rather than as resistance to manage. Team members will ask whether AI is coming for their jobs, and he calls that a legitimate question.

His approach is open discussion covering what AI is, what it will be used for, the benefits, and the pitfalls, followed by a direct statement of intent. The tool exists to help people do the job better, and in his firm, to produce better results for clients. It is not there to replace them. What it will replace is the repetitive work they did not enjoy anyway.

McCready frames the whole thing as change management, which is one of the themes in his upcoming book, Built to Run. His position is that how a leader rolls out change determines whether the team trusts the change, and that the organization will look to the leader for how to interpret any new technology. Silence from the top gets filled by the version of the story the team already fears.

Firms Rebuild Their Billing Model Because Clients Will Stop Paying for Work AI Does

Michael P. McCready, founder and Managing Partner of McCready Law, calls these questions existential for the practice of law, and he separates the threat to the profession from the threat to the pricing model.

His firm runs on contingency fees rather than billable hours, which changes where the gain lands. A case that once took 100 hours might take 50 with AI. The firm delivers results more efficiently, clients get better outcomes without the same time investment, and the practice becomes more profitable. Nothing about that model breaks.

The billable hour is a different situation. McCready’s prediction is blunt: “Lawyers who use AI are going to replace lawyers that don’t use AI.” He adds that clients will demand it rather than wait for firms to volunteer it.

The deeper change is to how the profession trains people. Law firms have historically assigned first, second, and third year associates the grunt work, billed clients for it, and produced trained lawyers as a byproduct. McCready describes clients now refusing that arrangement: they will pay a senior partner more per hour and decline to fund the day-to-day work AI handles. He pairs that with a warning in the other direction, naming real danger in people believing they can act as their own lawyer with a chatbot, which is why a lawyer still signs off on the work product.

Founders Remove Themselves as the Pinch Point by Keeping Only the Work Nobody Else Will Do

Every founder I coach eventually reaches this realization, and it usually arrives later than it should. Michael P. McCready, founder and Managing Partner of McCready Law, describes the trap plainly: anyone who starts a business has worn every hat and probably believes they are the best person for every job. He fell into it and says it took a long time to accept otherwise.

The turn came when he named the problem himself. “It got to the point that I was the pinch point. And I recognized that.” His team’s reaction tells you how long the condition had been visible: they already knew. The value was in the founder reaching it, because he was the one holding back the firm’s growth and he was the only one who could change it.

What he does now is a filter rather than a purge. A founder must identify what only they can do, delegate everything else, and keep overseeing what they delegated, because delegation does not mean the work disappears from your attention. The skill, as he describes it, is focusing on what drives the business forward that nobody else will do, and trusting the team with the rest.

McCready’s metaphor for the difficulty is hanging off a cliff with one vine left to hold, and the instruction is to let go of the vine. The decision rule underneath it is the useful part: if someone else on your team will do the work acceptably, holding it makes you the constraint.

Leaders Apply Four Principles to Introduce AI Without Losing Control of It

PrincipleWhat it means in practiceNamed evidence from this interview
Assume adoption has already happenedWrite the policy for a firm already using AI, not for one deciding whether to startMcCready treats unmonitored use across a firm of more than 170 team members in 13 offices as the condition a policy must address, starting with the data-sharing default most staff have never seen
Attach accountability to a personRequire a named human to sign off on every AI output and keep an audit trail behind itMcCready applies the sign-off requirement in a personal injury practice where an unchecked hallucination would reach a client or a court
Name the job fear before the team doesHold open discussions on what AI is for, what it will replace, and what it will notMcCready pairs that with the explicit statement that AI replaces repetitive work rather than people, and ties the rollout to the change management theme running through his book Built to Run
Keep only the work nobody else will doIdentify what only the founder will do, delegate the rest, and keep overseeing itMcCready named himself the pinch point holding back firm growth, and the delegation that followed supported expansion to 13 offices across seven states over 27 years

Quotes from This Episode

  • “I’m an entrepreneur, I’m a businessman, who happens to be a lawyer.” — Michael P. McCready, Founder and Managing Partner, McCready Law
  • “Everybody had faith in me but myself.” — Michael P. McCready, Founder and Managing Partner, McCready Law
  • “No matter what business you’re in, the most important asset are your people.” — Michael P. McCready, Founder and Managing Partner, McCready Law
  • “You have a limited bandwidth and you have to understand how to train the people that report to you.” — Michael P. McCready, Founder and Managing Partner, McCready Law
  • “You cannot ignore that AI is going to be the future.” — Michael P. McCready, Founder and Managing Partner, McCready Law

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a small or mid-sized business really need a written AI policy?

Michael P. McCready, founder and Managing Partner of McCready Law, argues yes, on the basis that employees are already using AI whether leadership knows it or not, which makes the policy a response to a current condition rather than a future one. His specific concern is that the default setting on consumer LLMs shares data to improve the system, and that a partner may know to disable it while a paralegal handling client files does not. Glenn Gow, The Scaling Executive Coach and host of The Scaling Executive Podcast, works with executives on exactly this gap, where the organization looks to the leader for direction on new technology and gets silence instead.

How should a leader introduce AI to a team worried about losing their jobs?

Michael P. McCready treats the question as legitimate rather than as resistance, and holds open discussions with his team covering what AI is, what it will be used for, and both its benefits and its pitfalls. He states plainly that the tool exists to help people do their jobs better and to deliver better client results, and that what it will replace is the repetitive work they already disliked. McCready frames the whole rollout as change management, which is a core theme of his upcoming book Built to Run, on the basis that how a leader introduces change determines whether the team trusts it.

How will AI change what law firms charge clients?

Michael P. McCready says AI will not replace lawyers, but that lawyers who use AI will replace lawyers who do not, and that clients will demand the change rather than wait for firms to offer it. At McCready Law, which works on contingency fees, a case that once took 100 hours might take 50, which produces better client outcomes and a more profitable firm without disturbing the pricing model. The pressure lands hardest on billable-hour firms, where clients are refusing to keep paying for the junior associate grunt work that trained new lawyers, preferring to pay a senior partner a higher rate for less total billed time.

Executives Work with Glenn Gow to Scale Their Companies by Scaling Themselves First

Glenn Gow is The Scaling Executive Coach. He coaches ambitious executives into the CEO seat and CEOs into successful exits. With 25 years as a CEO and 5 years in venture capital, Glenn helps leaders scale their companies by scaling themselves first. If this conversation was useful, you can apply for executive coaching with Glenn Gow or apply to be a guest on The Scaling Executive Podcast.

Listen to the full episode of the podcast here.

Glenn Gow
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.